Five Star Automotive Expands Indiana Footprint with Seven-Store Acquisition
Event summary
- The Presidio Group advised Dreyer & Reinbold on the sale of seven Indiana dealerships to Five Star Automotive Group, closing November 16, 2026.
- The transaction included three Indianapolis dealerships (BMW North, Infiniti, Mini) and four in Greenwood (BMW, Infiniti, Subaru, Volkswagen).
- Five Star now operates 13 dealerships in Central Indiana, expanding its presence in the Indianapolis market.
- The Reinbold family retains Dreyer & Reinbold Racing, its IndyCar team with over 25 years of competition history.
The big picture
The transaction reflects the ongoing consolidation in automotive retail, with buyers prioritizing high-quality brands and strategic market positions. Five Star's expansion in Indiana aligns with broader industry trends of selective capital deployment toward luxury and sought-after franchises. The deal also highlights the strategic importance of real estate assets in dealership M&A.
What we're watching
- Consolidation Trends
- How the pace of luxury dealership acquisitions will affect regional market dominance.
- Brand Selectivity
- Whether Five Star can sustain growth by focusing on high-demand brands like BMW and Subaru.
- Family Business Dynamics
- The impact of generational transitions on dealership valuations and buyer interest.
