Smithfield Survey Reveals Toppings as Key Differentiator in Pizza Market

  • Smithfield Culinary's Guest Check survey of 2,000 U.S. pizza consumers found 46% prioritize toppings over crust, sauce, or cheese.
  • 79% of respondents have made special efforts to try specific pizzas, including traveling 25+ miles.
  • 27% of consumers identify as 'Meat Maximalists,' with 93% believing pepperoni will never go out of style.
  • Survey conducted Sept. 3–10, 2026, with a margin of error of ±2 percentage points.

The survey highlights a strategic opportunity for pizza operators to focus on high-quality toppings, particularly meat, to meet evolving consumer preferences. This aligns with broader industry trends toward personalized and experiential dining, where unique flavors and regional specialties drive customer engagement. Smithfield Culinary's findings suggest that operators prioritizing bold, flavorful toppings could gain a competitive edge in a crowded market.

Menu Innovation
How pizza operators will leverage topping preferences to differentiate their offerings and drive customer loyalty.
Regional Trends
Whether the demand for regional pizza styles will grow, influencing supply chains and menu development.
Meat Demand
The pace at which meat-heavy pizza options will expand, given the 27% of consumers identifying as 'Meat Maximalists.'