Replay Sports Cards Launches First Franchise-Owned Store in Indiana

Event summary

  • Replay Sports Cards opens its first franchisee-owned store in Seymour, Indiana, on February 28, 2026.
  • The shop is operated by partners Josh Stigdon (attorney) and Jason Buckel (logistics expert).
  • This marks Replay's expansion into franchising after years of corporate-owned locations.
  • The store will host a grand opening in late spring and plans community events and charitable initiatives.

The big picture

Replay Sports Cards is modernizing the traditional local card shop by blending modern retail with community-focused experiences. The shift to franchising allows for faster expansion while maintaining a local feel. The sports collectibles market continues to grow, driven by nostalgia and digital engagement, making this a strategic move to capture a broader audience.

What we're watching

Franchise Model Scaling
Whether Replay can maintain brand consistency while expanding through franchisees.
Community Engagement
The impact of local events and charitable initiatives on customer loyalty and foot traffic.
Market Penetration
The pace at which Replay can establish a presence in new geographic markets.